Erythritol, Allulose or Maltitol? How Sweeteners Change Your Net Carbs

Bar chart: how much of each sweetener counts toward net carbs. Table sugar 100%, maltitol, sorbitol, xylitol and isomalt 50%, erythritol 0%, allulose 0%, stevia and monk fruit 0%.

Two chocolate bars can list the same total carbohydrate and still land very differently on a low-carb day. The difference is usually the sweetener. Here's how the common ones compare, and why we choose the ones we do.

Why the sweetener matters

The Nutrition Facts panel lumps every sugar alcohol into one line, and allulose doesn't get its own line at all. To count net carbs you have to know which sweetener is in the product, and that means reading the ingredient list.

Erythritol

Erythritol is a sugar alcohol that is mostly absorbed and then passed out of the body without being used for energy. It has close to zero calories per gram and is the reason many of our ChocoRite chocolates can carry so little net carb. Most low-carb shoppers subtract all of it.

Allulose

Allulose is a rare sugar found in small amounts in figs and raisins. It tastes and browns like sugar but supplies very few calories, and FDA allows it to be left out of the Total and Added Sugars lines. We use it with stevia in our ChocoRite Natural chocolates. It can be subtracted in full.

Maltitol, sorbitol, xylitol and isomalt

These sugar alcohols are partly digested, so they still count. A common rule of thumb is to subtract only half. Maltitol in particular is used in a lot of "sugar-free" candy because it behaves like sugar in chocolate, and it is also the one most likely to upset stomachs in larger amounts. That's why our chocolates are maltitol free.

Stevia and monk fruit

These high-intensity sweeteners are used in such small amounts that they add essentially no carbohydrate. You won't need to subtract anything for them.

Glycerin

Glycerin keeps protein bars soft. It shows up in total carbohydrate, and we subtract it when we count net carbs on our own products.

Put it to work

Our free net carb calculator does the math for you. Type in the numbers from any label, ours or anyone else's, and it shows net carbs per serving and whether the product fits our keto rule of 5 g net carbs or less.

Net carbs is not an FDA-defined term, and people respond to sweeteners differently. Talk with your doctor or dietitian about what's right for you.